Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Jazz and Improv

I've been listening to a lot of Dave Brubeck lately, probably because he recently passed away. I have a habit of getting into musicians right after they die- probably because they are in the press so much, and because I have a knack for taking things for granted till they go away. I got super into Run DMC after Jam Master J died, super into Warren Zevon when he died in 2003. When Pavarotti died someone posted a video of him singing with James Brown, and I got super into James Brown.

So I've been listening to a Dave Brubeck album on heavy rotation, and the the thought that keeps coming back to me is; how much of this is improvised? To the untrained ear (read; mine) it seems like it would be hard to know what's being played is prepared and what is spontaneous. The album was recorded in front of an audience, and they burst into applause at the start of each song, so they obviously recognize the starts- but what about the rest? How would I know what's practiced and what's improvised?

I think I'd have more respect for the song knowing it was mostly improvised. "Take 5" for example, is an incredible piece of music. I've always assumed it was practiced and perfected over the course of many hours of effort. But what if it was found through improvisation? What if the core of the song was a simple discovery made while playing with the rest of the Quartet?

Why do jazz musicians improvise? Is it for the same reasons improvisers improvise? Do they do it with a purpose in mind; to work out a tricky piece, maybe, or to find alternatives to what they already have on paper? Is it just for fun, as in just strictly for fun? Do they see it as a tool or an end game? Would a jazz musician ever record their improvisations and sell them like they do their crafted work? How do jazz musicians view those who improvise? Poorly ("if you can't write, improvise")? With respect? What role does improv play in the jazz world?

It makes me wonder if people at improv shows ever wonder that same thing. Is there ever any confusion about what's made up and what's preplanned? A lot of people scoff at the idea that I attend regular rehearsals for improv- "What do you rehearse??" they ask. So it seems likely there is some level of confusion or even distrust when they are told the entire show is improvised.

I'm sure I'm not the first to draw parallels between  musical improvisation and comedic improvisation, but I'd love to hear from musicians what their views on the matter are.