Sunday, November 11, 2012

How to Start a Scene

I've been really focused on the start of scenes lately.

It started after reading this article with TJ Jagodowski where talks about how TJ and Dave treat the first few seconds of their shows;

"What we would refer to it as trying to get a read on the “heat” and the “weight.” The heat being the intimacy of the relationship – anything from strangers to being married and soul mates for 50 years and anything in between. And the weight being what is already in the room with you - what does it feel like is already going on? Like, “Oh my God, it feels like our common best friend is in a coffin in the other room.” Or it feels like one of us needs to sell a car today…" TJ Jagodowski.

Hearing this, my initial reaction was, "everything I know about improv is wrong."

There are two basic schools of thought on how a scene should start: "3 Line Scene", and "Everything But 3 Line Scene".

In conservatory level 3 my teacher Rachael Mason drilled us on the vital importance of 3 line scenes. "Get the who, what and where of the scene out of the way as fast as possible", she'd say. And it makes sense; I've been in many a scene where we're 2 mins in and I don't know where we are, I think I'm a doctor, my partner thinks they are an octopus  and neither of us have names. I get it. Get the bare facts out in the open, if not for the benefit of the audience than just for the people on stage so they know what's going on. Then set it and forget it; move on and play the hell out of the scene.

At the same time I was taking this class, I was learning more about the Tj and Dave philosophy. Dave Pasiquesi says what the start of a scene needs is everything but the who, what, where; scenes need to be felt before they can be told. It's not who you are, but who you are to each other, that really matters. This is where the Heat and the Weight come into play. Tj and Dave might not know if they're siblings or coworkers or cousins or roommates, but they have a sense of how well they know each other; it's rare to see one of them treat the other like a brother and the other treat them like a perfect stranger. Eventually the finer points are fleshed out, but they are done so because the big stuff is already in place.

So which one is right? I have no clue. I suspect the right answer is based in context; if I'm playing slow enough to take the time to feel out a scene, do. But if I'm in a montage or the 3rd beat of a Harold, there's no time for that.

Here's that Tj interview where he describes the Heat and the Weight.

lTJ Interview


Saturday, November 10, 2012

Success?

How do you define a successful improv show? That's something I've never understood. When dealing with something as abstract and subjective as art, even more so live performance, even even more so something as ethereal as improv comedy, it's near impossible to definitively call a show a success.

What makes it a success? The audience's reaction? Okay, maybe it's that. Judged off what? How much they laughed? How much they clapped? What if the show was more touching than it was funny, which can happen. If only humans made other sounds of validating approval besides laughter and clapping. Like if a scene was really honest, or touching, or honest, or heartbreaking; what would the audience's reaction sound like? I'm so trained to only listen for laughter and clapping I don't know if I would recognize an audience's reaction otherwise (and I'd have to do something honest or heartbreaking to warrant it first).

So maybe it's the opposite- a good show is a good show if you think it's a good show. But who is 'you'? The  whole team? You as an individual performer? What do you go off of? If you had fun? If you liked the content? Your work as a piece in the show? How much fun you had?

Here are ways I don't think the success of a show can be exclusively determined:

"The audience liked it": Well, audiences like 2 and Half Men, bull fights, and watching Christians fed to the lions, so what do they know? As a performer, is it your job to follow the desires of the audience? Especially in improv, where you'll get "Dildo" and "gynecologist" for every suggestion. Does the audience know what they really want?

"We had a lot of fun": You can have a lot of fun going on stage and telling inside jokes, or playing a flock of emus for 25 mins without speaking, that doesn't guarantee it's a good show. If having fun is my primary goal during a show, I fear it could lead to self-indulgence. Also, I know how to have fun in a show- get out a bunch, do a lot of crazy, interesting scenes- but just like what the audience really wants, do I know what would bring me the most fun? Maybe focusing on the show as a whole, trying to make sure it's a strong piece and worry less about my personal part, would bring about the most enjoyment. So we've created two separate questions: "how do I have fun in the show", and "how do I have the most amount of fun".

"I pushed myself/tried new things on stage/stepped out of my comfort zone": I think we're getting closer, but this still rings false to me. If your goal is to test yourself, try new things, etc, what makes this a show and not just a rehearsal with an audience? This leads to the bigger question of "when is it a show and when is it a reh?" Sounds like it'd be pretty easy to answer, but I've been in a lot of situations that seem to blur the line between practicing and performing.

Also, while there are few things more important than stepping out of your comfort zone and trying new things in improv, doing it in a show does not guarantee a successful show, if anything it might lead to a weaker one. We are talking intention vs consequence now- people watching me perform for the first time won't know I'm trying really hard to get better at playing big characters, they might just see a guy who is playing characters poorly. It's not youth-league soccer, where effort is automatically factored into the overall quality of the event- at the end of the day, there's an expectation that I will be putting my best foot forward. 

Okay, I think I've driven this into the ground enough. I'll just say this- in my experience, 90% of the time you can just tell if it was a good show or a bad show. No deliberation needed- you step off stage and you know. But I'm always interested in that remaining 10% because it says a lot about my goals as a performer, and how I view the audience.

And some of you might read this and say- "Wow, you waaay over-thought this. A good show is good when ____". If you have that answer to fill in the blank, please share it.

Friday, November 9, 2012

Comedy and Self Awareness

I've been trying to get a casting agent. I'd like to start doing commercials, voiceovers or extra work. I don't think I have enough experience to nab an agent, my resume is a little light, but I figure I might as well start down that path now. I'm really interested in earning some amount of money, no matter how small, from some kind of artistic pursuit whether it's comedy or film or writing. I'm one of a million people in Chicago currently trying to achieve that goal.

A lot of my more experienced friends have been giving me some great advice for how to put together packets and what to do if I get to talk to agencies. Most of it is similar to interviewing for jobs; dress nice, come prepared, don't bad mouth anyone or anything, for any reason.

But then there's a whole dimension involved that I've never given much thought. The ability to look someone in the eye with strict confidence and say: "I'm *this* type of person. When people view me, they make *these* assumptions about me. *This* is how people see me.

So we're talking about basic sociology here: looking glass theory. One of the first concepts I learned in college, it states that we define ourselves through other's perceptions of ourselves. CH Cooley, who developed the theory, puts it perfectly; "I am not what I think I am and I am not what you think I am; I am what I think that you think I am." How awesome is that? In every day life we let other people's views of us shape how we act, think, and react. It's rarely a conscious decision, but rather happens in a myriad of subtle ways that we don't always detect.

On stage, it means knowing how the audience sees you. The minute you walk on stage, even before saying a word, the audience takes in your clothes, your posture, your size and shape, your race and your gender, and their brains make millisecond assumptions about who you are as a person, and how you will act on stage. A performer who can properly anticipate how an audience will receive them can do wonders with that information. Look at Steve Martin- making the choice to come out clean shaven with a sharp suit, at the height of the free flowing 70s, immediately cut a strong stage picture that drew people in. Then, once his act started, full of roaming nonsequiturs and jokes lacking any clear punch lines, his look became that much more absurd.

Closer to Chicago, you have people like Timmy Mayse. He's tall, scrawny, skinny as a pole; basically the same body type as myself. He projects a very specific image to an audience, and he's fully aware of it. He creates humor through the simple juxtaposition of his characters and the actor playing them. In a given 20 min. set you'll see him play fat rednecks, an old WW2 vet, a young punk kid, and usually a horse or some type of barnyard animal. It's inspiring to watch someone with such a distinct look exhibit a range of characters.

So all this to say- how do others see me? How do I see myself? It's hard to separate "how I think people see me" from "how I want people to see me". I want people to like me; that's fairly common, right? I want people to see me as nice, funny, handsome, smart (smart is a big one for sure). But do they? If they do, in what ways do they show that they do?

Once again I've created more questions than answers lol.

Thursday, November 8, 2012

Playing to My Strengths

Yesterday in class at the Annoyance we did an exercise where we did scenes as animals. We couldn't talk or anything, just embody the animals we were assigned. I hated it. Hate is a strong word, but for the 3 and a half minutes I was doing that exercise, prancing around a room of people as an ostrich, I hated it.

Our teacher warned us we'd look stupid. The point was to push us out of our comfort zone of the characters we usually play. "It's not something you'd usually do on stage during a show, but it's a good thing to do in rehs."

The last time I disliked an improv exercise as much as this was in Second City Conservatory a weeks back. We had half a day of musical improv, and I didn't enjoy it one bit. We were taught very basic techniques to doing musically improvised scenes. I felt like it was a giant waste of time. Not of my time, but everyone else's.

I've done improv long enough to know what I'm bad at. I don't play high energy, I don't play a wide range of characters, and I can't sing. I can't dance, I can't rap, I can't act very well either. These are things I've come to terms with on stage.

Those are also the things I'm the least interested in doing on stage. Maybe it's a chicken and the egg situation; I'm not interested in singing because I'm terrible at it, I'm terrible at it because I'm not interested in it. When I picture "playing characters" on stage, I see unrealistic, cartoony over the top voices and unbelievable physicality that distracts from developing relationships or content during the scene. That's not what it means to play a character on stage, but that's what I see when I visualize it. I've always been more interested in playing a shade of myself on stage, with a strong point of view.

And it's not that I'm completely not interested in them; singing, playing strong characters, moving more than 2 steps in a given scene. It's just right now I have a very clear direction I want to pursue with improv. I want to do slow, grounded, focused scenes that rely on characters close the actors portraying them. So basically TJ and Dave. I don't think I'll get anywhere that good for years to come, and that's why I want to spend all my energy racing towards that goal- any time I spend going towards other goals within improv seems like it's taking me further from my goal. So what should I do? Work on the areas I know I love the most, or suck it up and widen my spectrum? I know for a fact I've heard TJ himself say "take in everything: every form, every style, everything you can." So what do you do when your improv hero who I'm trying to exclusively copy is telling me to do everything else too?

So whenever I'm forced to step out of my comfort zone, to focus on my weaknesses in improv, I get defensive. I show less than 100% enthusiasm, I criticize my work more harshly, and most importantly, I don't have fun. Susan Messing says if you aren't having fun on stage, you're the asshole. The burden is on you to make sure you're finding ways to have fun no matter the scene or the style. So I'm being an asshole, and I need to stop.


Wednesday, November 7, 2012

Warm Ups

I don't like warm ups. Warming up before rehs, classes and shows is a pretty fundamental part of the improv experience, but I've never enjoyed it. Probably because I don't need them. Well, it's not that I don't need them. that sounds cocky. I guess it's that they don't help me. I am not an energetic person. I'm passionate, I've been called intense, but I'm not high-energy, in real life or on stage. Probably has something to do with the fact that I only eat about a meal and a half a day and tend to sleep 9 hours a night. I'm like a sloth. 

The goal of warmups are: to raise your energy, to reign in your sense of concentration, and to get you and your teammates on the same page. I'm all about checking in before rehearsing or performing. In college my team would sit around and gab about our day and totally BS for like 45 mins before actually getting around to improv. I think it's an essential element to strong cohesive teams- you have to be comfortable around each other off stage before you can be onstage. It's the difference between 'working' with someone and 'playing' with them- you don't need to know a person that well to work them, but if you are gonna play with them, you gotta know them. 

Some people REALLY need warmups. They want to shake off their day and transform into someone else before getting onto stage. And I find the transformation incredible to watch. But for me, I'm pretty much exactly the same off stage as I am on. I talk a little bit more onstage, I think, but my tone, energy and physicality is almost the exact same. I don't know if this is a good thing or a bad thing; I am either playing to my strengths as a performer or running from my weaknesses. 

So I don't get much from the physical warmups. And at the same time, the mental warmups, based in patterns and memorization, tend to put me even more in my head than I already am, which I feel like isn't conducive to good improv. I'm already a plotter and a planner, a chess player on stage trying to think the whole show into creation. Playing 10 mins of games that warm up my brain are only going to intensify that. 

So until I can turn myself into a more physical performer, I will continue to just pay lip service during the warm ups and relish the small talk with the team before the scenes begin. 

Tuesday, November 6, 2012

What I Learned From iO

"No student knows his subject: the most he knows is where and how to find out the things he does not know." Woodrow Wilson.

I moved to Chicago for two reasons; sociology and comedy; specifically University of Chicago's soc. grad. program and iO's comedy programs. Almost two years later, and I haven't been accepted into University of Chicago (keep your fingers crossed, I reapply in December),but I recently graduated from iO's improv program. A year and a half of classes, 7 different levels and over 70 people in my 'grade' has given me a lot to think about.

My first realization was also the most basic: people from Kansas can be funny. I had a lot of trepidation about moving to Chicago; I was afraid I'd find out I was only "Kansas Funny", and not "funny". But when I learned that Del Close, one of the founders of iO, was born and raised in Manhattan, KS, I felt a wave of relief. I gave myself permission to believe that you can be funny, or talented or creative, regardless of where you grow up.

My first iO teacher taught me the importance of not making your art about your art. Now, whether or not you consider improv an art is a whole other conversation, so for the sake of today we'll agree that it is. In whatever art you are producing, one of the fastest ways to burn out is to only take in that same type of art. If you play piano and all you do in your free time is listen to other people play piano and read about pianos and practice playing piano, it's gonna have an impact on your actual performances. Similarly if all I ever do is go see improv and talk to my improv friends about improv and read improv blogs, my actual improv will suffer. I'll start doing improv scenes about improv. A good artist takes in inspiration from a spectrum of sources and media. Our teacher would have us do book and cd swaps with our classmates to introduce us to new music and authors. He encouraged us to talk to new people, to follow the news, to take in as much as possible from the world, because it would all become material for our improv.

I remember a conversation with an older improviser as he gave me a ride home after a show. We were talking about the next round of SNL auditions, and the drama that usually ensues in terms of who gets to audition, who was snubbed, etc. He said, "You can't get caught up in what you think you deserve. You're not entitled to anything- all you can do is do good work, and hope eventually people take notice. If a performer starts thinking they are unappreciated, that they aren't getting the opportunities they deserve, that others are getting more than their fair share of attention and respect, it's poison. Remove jealousy, remove desires for instant success and full validation, and just focus on the content of my work. If the work is good, everything else will come.

Finally, the biggest lesson I found from iO was the importance of building relationships on stage. As I went through classes I experienced what I can only assume every new improviser experienced. At first, I just did scenes; sometimes thought-out initiations, "oh this would be a funny way to start the scene", other times with nothing. After a few months, after what felt like a hundred scenes taking place in a cubicle, a kitchen, or a high school, after holding dozens of improv coffee mugs and hours of improv shoveling, improv mopping, and improv weddings,  I started thinking, "I want to do what hasn't been done on stage ever before". A lot of my scenes involved outer space and/or wizards. I had burnt myself out on the normal and the everyday and I wanted to test the limits of my imagination. After a few more months, that began to bore me too; you can only have so many wizard scenes. I entered into a phase of "Let me just be me" on stage- taking my mood or energy and letting that influence my initiations. I quickly realized all my scenes involved a skinny, white guy who was either nervous or overly excited, usually depending on the time of day. Those scenes got old fast too.

And I fell upon a realization- if I had been doing improv for less than a year and I felt like I'd seen every possible scene you could do, think about how my teachers felt. Imagine teaching for 3 hours a week for 10 straight years- how improv scenes would you see? A thousand? ten thousand? How many times would you watch snotty brothers and sisters fight about who mom loves more? How many times would you hear neighbors fight about why they ran over the other's cat? I shudder to think. So It's starting to dawn on me it's not about the what and the who of the scene that matters, that makes it worth watching. It's gotta be something more than that. iO stresses the relationship; it's not who you are, but who you are to each other. A scene about two coworkers is just another office scene, until we start to explore the dynamic between them. Do they act like an older brother and a younger brother? Are they always competing against each other? Is one the leader and the other is the lackey? Suddenly a world of possibilities has been created where there was just an office scene a minute before.

Monday, November 5, 2012

Day 1: The Student

First of all, let me discuss some thing most people already know about me. I love comedy. It is one of the few activities, besides sociology and eating, that I enjoy thinking about as much as doing. I spend hours every day daydreaming about the ins and outs of comedy. But I never do anything with those thoughts- rarely share them, never write them down.

I also love being a student. I've always loved school: I do well in structured learning environments. I like having a clear purpose, I like setting goals, I like challenges and obstacles. Even more than that, I love being confused. I love the sensation of not understanding; of taking what information I have and using it to make sense of out of something that's beyond my reach intellectually. I think we are raised to avoid that which confuses us. If we can put it off or ignore it, we usually do. But I've always found being confused to be an adventure, and find great satisfaction in leading myself through it to clarity. 

It's because of these two loves I moved to Chicago in 2010 to study comedy. Now, two years later, I am interested in continuing my education in a different way. I'm going to keep a journal, a public journal at that, of my thoughts and discoveries in improv, to see how I'm being affected by what I'm learning. 

Like Kurt Vonnegut in Breakfast in Champions, I’m writing this stuff down to make more room in my head. I've got a year and a half of improv classes rattling around in there. I need to start organizing my thoughts, laying them out on the bed to find out what fits and what’s still confusing. Before I come to the next fork in the road, I need to know what areas to focus on.  

For some reason, it's important to me that this blog doesn't feel like a teaching tool. My goal isn't to teach anything, but rather to figure out what I’m trying to learn. The more a teacher speaks, the more you learn. But the more the student speaks, the more the student can be taught. My hope is that my views and notes will be relatable to those studying comedy, or pursuing the arts in general.

My immediate goal is this: 30 days, 30 posts of improv notes and reactions. To sort my brain out, to file and save some of the amazing information I've been taught, and to establish my views on improv and comedy in general.

If you care to help me as I do this over the next month, please leave comments, suggest books, share your own stories with me.