It started after reading this article with TJ Jagodowski where talks about how TJ and Dave treat the first few seconds of their shows;
"What we would refer to it as trying to get a read on the “heat” and the “weight.” The heat being the intimacy of the relationship – anything from strangers to being married and soul mates for 50 years and anything in between. And the weight being what is already in the room with you - what does it feel like is already going on? Like, “Oh my God, it feels like our common best friend is in a coffin in the other room.” Or it feels like one of us needs to sell a car today…" TJ Jagodowski.
Hearing this, my initial reaction was, "everything I know about improv is wrong."
There are two basic schools of thought on how a scene should start: "3 Line Scene", and "Everything But 3 Line Scene".
In conservatory level 3 my teacher Rachael Mason drilled us on the vital importance of 3 line scenes. "Get the who, what and where of the scene out of the way as fast as possible", she'd say. And it makes sense; I've been in many a scene where we're 2 mins in and I don't know where we are, I think I'm a doctor, my partner thinks they are an octopus and neither of us have names. I get it. Get the bare facts out in the open, if not for the benefit of the audience than just for the people on stage so they know what's going on. Then set it and forget it; move on and play the hell out of the scene.
At the same time I was taking this class, I was learning more about the Tj and Dave philosophy. Dave Pasiquesi says what the start of a scene needs is everything but the who, what, where; scenes need to be felt before they can be told. It's not who you are, but who you are to each other, that really matters. This is where the Heat and the Weight come into play. Tj and Dave might not know if they're siblings or coworkers or cousins or roommates, but they have a sense of how well they know each other; it's rare to see one of them treat the other like a brother and the other treat them like a perfect stranger. Eventually the finer points are fleshed out, but they are done so because the big stuff is already in place.
So which one is right? I have no clue. I suspect the right answer is based in context; if I'm playing slow enough to take the time to feel out a scene, do. But if I'm in a montage or the 3rd beat of a Harold, there's no time for that.
Here's that Tj interview where he describes the Heat and the Weight.
lTJ Interview