Saturday, November 10, 2012

Success?

How do you define a successful improv show? That's something I've never understood. When dealing with something as abstract and subjective as art, even more so live performance, even even more so something as ethereal as improv comedy, it's near impossible to definitively call a show a success.

What makes it a success? The audience's reaction? Okay, maybe it's that. Judged off what? How much they laughed? How much they clapped? What if the show was more touching than it was funny, which can happen. If only humans made other sounds of validating approval besides laughter and clapping. Like if a scene was really honest, or touching, or honest, or heartbreaking; what would the audience's reaction sound like? I'm so trained to only listen for laughter and clapping I don't know if I would recognize an audience's reaction otherwise (and I'd have to do something honest or heartbreaking to warrant it first).

So maybe it's the opposite- a good show is a good show if you think it's a good show. But who is 'you'? The  whole team? You as an individual performer? What do you go off of? If you had fun? If you liked the content? Your work as a piece in the show? How much fun you had?

Here are ways I don't think the success of a show can be exclusively determined:

"The audience liked it": Well, audiences like 2 and Half Men, bull fights, and watching Christians fed to the lions, so what do they know? As a performer, is it your job to follow the desires of the audience? Especially in improv, where you'll get "Dildo" and "gynecologist" for every suggestion. Does the audience know what they really want?

"We had a lot of fun": You can have a lot of fun going on stage and telling inside jokes, or playing a flock of emus for 25 mins without speaking, that doesn't guarantee it's a good show. If having fun is my primary goal during a show, I fear it could lead to self-indulgence. Also, I know how to have fun in a show- get out a bunch, do a lot of crazy, interesting scenes- but just like what the audience really wants, do I know what would bring me the most fun? Maybe focusing on the show as a whole, trying to make sure it's a strong piece and worry less about my personal part, would bring about the most enjoyment. So we've created two separate questions: "how do I have fun in the show", and "how do I have the most amount of fun".

"I pushed myself/tried new things on stage/stepped out of my comfort zone": I think we're getting closer, but this still rings false to me. If your goal is to test yourself, try new things, etc, what makes this a show and not just a rehearsal with an audience? This leads to the bigger question of "when is it a show and when is it a reh?" Sounds like it'd be pretty easy to answer, but I've been in a lot of situations that seem to blur the line between practicing and performing.

Also, while there are few things more important than stepping out of your comfort zone and trying new things in improv, doing it in a show does not guarantee a successful show, if anything it might lead to a weaker one. We are talking intention vs consequence now- people watching me perform for the first time won't know I'm trying really hard to get better at playing big characters, they might just see a guy who is playing characters poorly. It's not youth-league soccer, where effort is automatically factored into the overall quality of the event- at the end of the day, there's an expectation that I will be putting my best foot forward. 

Okay, I think I've driven this into the ground enough. I'll just say this- in my experience, 90% of the time you can just tell if it was a good show or a bad show. No deliberation needed- you step off stage and you know. But I'm always interested in that remaining 10% because it says a lot about my goals as a performer, and how I view the audience.

And some of you might read this and say- "Wow, you waaay over-thought this. A good show is good when ____". If you have that answer to fill in the blank, please share it.

No comments:

Post a Comment